The Island of Dr. Moreau / Lord of the Flies

<---------->




So after reading The Island of Dr. Moreau, I begin to think that the novel holds a close resemblance to Golding's Lord of the Flies on various levels.

Foremost, both novels take place on an island. It is quite interesting to note the use of the island in such books to explore human nature and moral philosophies. The island serves as an "untainted" environment from humanity and social structures. Thus, an island will bring out the true nature in organisms--both humans and animals.

Also, the theme of civilized societal structure resonates with both novels. The laws that Dr. Moreau creates serves as a structure to hold the animals on the island in order. Also, the religious undertone of Dr. Moreau's laws and control further add civility and structure to the island. Similarly, in Lord of the Flies, the boys do begin by making some type of order. They try to hold meetings and assign leadership and control.

Finally, the theme of animal vs. human nature is explored in both novels. In the Island of Dr. Moreau, as Prendick sees the terror in the eyes of the these animal creatures he begins to attribute human qualities to these animals and feel empathy. Also, the puma's cries take on the form of a voice, once again juxtaposing the animal's instincts with those of human qualities. In Lord of the Flies, the boys become savages and go through a rapid process of "de-evolution." The humans nature we though innate is questioned and more animal/savage like nature is brought out.

Thus, although the two novels are ultimately investigating separate aspects of society, many of the underlying themes seem to parallel.